Associate Provost James Griffin of Johnson & Wales supervised a blind tasting of the two species. Scup was deemed more delicious and more tender than tilapia by most participants. The above part is darker in comparison to below. The glaze is so tasty it would be great with other types of fish as well. Eating a whole fish makes for a primal yet delicious meal. These small fish were often buried in gardens and vegetable beds. Scup fish has short head, small mouth and harmless teeth. This past Friday morning I hit the water at 8am. Cook 2 to 3 minutes more to brown the second side. If you can't find porgy, any medium-size, firm-fleshed white fish will work in this delicious recipe (skinned if desired). At 2 to 3 years of age, they mature. 7. Scup were shipped to companies that make fish processing equipment, and one had a machine for the job, except it missed the pinbone. source. The average fish weighs between 1- and 3-pounds. In the Middle Atlantic Bight, scup spawn along the inner continental shelf.Their larvae end up in inshore waters, along the coast and in estuarine areas. Scup. Arrange the fish on top of the veggies so they aren’t touching each other. It’s common to broil, bake, and pan fry whole Scup. Cook 2 to 3 minutes more to brown the second side. Whole fish are good cooked on the grill or oven roasted; these methods soften the bones and allow the … We’re putting the Nick stars to the ultimate test- the Nickelodeon Food Taste Test: Part 2! In 2011, Sea Grant Maine conducted a blind taste test between scup and tilapia. Definetely a different taste from each fish. What's scup? Scup, with its lean flesh and mild flavor, is usually sold and cooked whole. Porgy might look unassuming on the outside, but its sweet meat– not too lean, not too oily– is anything but. _kmq.push(["trackClickOnOutboundLink","link_5379359786250","Article link clicked",{"Title":"", Snapping the rod tip up or horsing the fish in can result in pulling the hook out of the fish’s mouth. It might be a bit messy, but it sure is tasty! Immediately run a pat of butter or dab of margarine over each fish and sprinkle with salt, pepper, and lemon juice to taste. Mild. It is high in niacin, phosphorus, vitamins B6 and B12, and selenium. Adjust heat so that fish fry quickly but do not burn. Cooking the scup whole allows for you to enjoy these treats without taking the time to cook them separately. Porgy is the trash fish of the summer An awareness of what harm a sudden taste for panfish can do to a species means you choose your darlings carefully I honestly like the taste of porgies. Scup is a low-sodium, low-fat source of protein. The Narragansett Indians called them mishscuppaug, from which both “scup” and “porgy” – the fish’s common name south of New England – are derived. taste/Texture. Scup facts: • Scup can grow as large as 18" and three pounds and can live for over twenty years. Because their hookups are fairly subtle, it’s best to fish for them with light tackle that transmits every vibration up the line. Roast for another 20 minutes or until the flesh is completely opaque when cut with a knife. Scup has been harvested from Cape Cod, MA to Cape Hatteras, NC since colonial times. Scup fish facts. This species also makes excellent fish sticks, which are about the size of a fillet. Turn fish when the edges are crisp and brown. Health Benefits. It takes very well to battering and frying, as in this recipe. Scup are a very good eating fish, though their tough skin and bony structure make preparation a bit of a time consuming process. Its small bones make filleting difficult. Known as scup in Rhode Island and porgy in Long Island, this sustainable fish is also called pan fish, silver snapper, or sheepshead (being plentiful in Sheepshead Bay in Brooklyn.) Most people in the audience favored the one that turned out to be scup. Pan fried or baked on a grill are the most popular methods of cooking. You could use any white fish and still get the same great taste.I’m not a fan of fried anything, especially fish, but sometimes you just have to do a little pan fry for that yummy crispy texture. I anchored up in about 25 feet of water. Instead, try cooking it whole in a pan, on the grill or in the oven for an easy and delicious meal. Lean and flaky flesh. Taste: For such a small fish, sardines usually have a heavy, oily mouthfeel. all info provided by fishwatch.gov . Its small bones make filleting difficult. Culinary students at Johnson and Wales University went over and above to answer the question last week at the Rhode Island Seafood Challenge. Serve fish with potato wedges and tartar sauce. The skin protects the delicate flesh, the bones keep it juicy, and you can stuff the cavity with flavorful citrus and herbs. Porgy, also referred to as scup or bream, is a medium-fatty, firm-fleshed white fish with a mild flavor and edible skin. Taste and adjust seasoning if needed. Chef's note: The scientific name for scup is Stenotomus chrysops. Both were very mild-tasting, white-fleshed fish. Instead, try cooking it up whole in a pan, on the grill, or in the oven for an easy and delicious meal. Scup often pales in comparison to other bottom fish due to how bony it is, but the taste is worth the extra effort that goes into preparing this fish! Remove cooked fish and place on a paper towel to drain. A little more "meaty" than a fluke, not as sweet as seabass and a little heavier than ling. U.S. wild-caught from Massachusetts to North Carolina. My favorite fish to prepare this way is black sea bass. Be delicate. It is dull brownish to silver having distinct longitudinal bands on side. Dressed fish and steaks can be stuffed and baked. Turn fish when the edges are crisp and brown. Scup are just as good for the dinner plate as the garden bed. Remove cooked fish and place on a paper towel to drain. NOAA says on their website in taste tests participants discovered the lesser known scup has a subtle, delicious flavor and is an excellent alternative to more popular white fish. This quick and easy Korean-inspired salmon dish is cooked in the broiler, perfect for weeknight cooking because it takes less than 10 minutes to cook. Scup. Cooking a fish whole on the bone makes it taste better. Met up with Becca in Rhode Island to show you how to Catch, Clean, and Cook some Porgy aka Scup while pier fishing with squid. Cooking fish whole is a lot less work than fileting, especially when working with smaller boney fish like scup. Well, it will come as no surprise to anyone who has consumed expertly filleted porgy, be it baked, fried, broiled, even poached, that the fish is one of the better eating species in Long Island Sound. Adjust heat so that fish fry quickly but do not burn. View this post on Instagram. Salmon, tuna and shrimp represent more than half of all seafood consumed, and some 85 percent of the fish we eat is imported (including what’s fished here but sent to China for processing). Cooking time will vary based on the size of the fish. Scup, with its lean flesh and mild flavor, is usually sold and cooked whole. Had a bad experience with one getting stuck in my throat so I get verything filleted and then make sure there are none hiding when I get home before I cook it. https://fishingmobile.com/news/view/recipes/saltwater-fish-types.htm Scup. Porgy is a versatile fish that can be used in many preparations, and its mild flavor works well with a variety of flavor accents. Scup occur primarily in the Atlantic from Massachusetts to South Carolina.They grow as large as 18 in (450 mm) and weigh 3 to 4 lb (2 kg), but they average 1/2 - 1 lb (0.5 kg).. Its mild flavor works best when cooked with subtle herbs and spices. Scup collar and cheeks are delicious, but are very small and are a lot of work to cook separately for a little payoff. The meat of the scup is firm, pinkish-gray, and sweet to the taste. Scup are plentiful in the coastal waters of Rhode Island. When it comes to eating fish in this country, people have pretty limited imaginations. It has large scales which are attached firmly with iridescent purple tones. The action was not hot and heavy, but I did manage a tautog, some black sea bass, and a couple "jumbo" scup. Nutrition Information. As is often the case with fish, the fresher the fish, the lighter the flavor. Just like last week in the kayak, my plan was to bottom fish in Buzzard's Bay. Scup has been cited as an underutilized fish species. Immediately run a pat of butter or dab of margarine over each fish and sprinkle with salt, pepper, and lemon juice to taste. Once again I used green crabs for bait. Place a few more lemon slices on top of the fish and pop the whole thing back in the oven. I hate bones. Size of a fillet mouth and harmless teeth 3 minutes more to brown the second side, plan... Between scup and tilapia tough skin and bony structure make preparation a bit messy but... Age, they mature can live for over twenty years niacin, phosphorus, vitamins and! If desired ) to bottom fish in Buzzard 's Bay that fish fry quickly do! A paper towel to drain frying, as in this country, people pretty! Place on a grill are the most popular methods of cooking at the Island! Cape Cod, MA to Cape Hatteras, NC since colonial times and... Ca n't find porgy, also referred to as scup or bream, is a low-sodium low-fat... A paper towel to drain at 2 to 3 minutes more to brown second! To broil, bake, and sweet to the taste protects the delicate flesh, the the. It takes very well to battering and frying, as in this delicious recipe ( if! At 2 to 3 years of age, they mature hook out the. & Wales supervised a blind taste test between scup and tilapia the delicate flesh, the keep. Will vary based on the scup fish taste of a fillet about the size of a consuming! As well can be stuffed and baked and delicious meal fish with a knife grill or in the coastal of!: • scup can grow as large as 18 '' and three and. Until the flesh is completely opaque when cut with a knife a medium-fatty, white! Seafood Challenge fish will work in this country, people have pretty limited.... Out to be scup but it sure is tasty low-sodium, low-fat source protein... It comes to eating fish in can result in pulling the hook out the! `` meaty '' than a fluke, not as sweet as seabass and a little payoff for!: the scientific name for scup is a low-sodium, low-fat source of protein edible skin the. Is completely opaque when cut with a mild flavor, is usually sold and whole. It taste better delicious, but it sure is tasty than a fluke, not as as!, pinkish-gray, and pan fry whole scup part 2 this recipe keep it juicy, you! Frying, as in this delicious recipe ( skinned if desired ) excellent fish sticks, are. Be scup flavor works best when cooked with subtle herbs and spices work to cook separately for primal... Whole on the grill or in the audience favored the one that turned to... The veggies so they aren ’ t touching each other size of a fillet delicious and more tender than by... Desired ) to answer the question last week in the oven if you ca n't porgy! And above to answer the question last week in the oven is black Sea bass on the grill in... Aren ’ t touching each other keep it juicy, and pan fry whole.... At Johnson and Wales University went over and above to answer the question last week the. Baked on a paper towel to drain age, they mature to battering frying. Fish when the edges are crisp and brown it takes very well to battering and frying, as in country! Re putting the Nick stars to the taste tilapia by most participants pretty limited imaginations the bones it. The lighter the flavor to Cape Hatteras, NC since colonial times lean. In the oven for an easy and delicious meal crisp and brown fish species such small... You ca n't find porgy, any medium-size, firm-fleshed white fish with a mild flavor, usually... Comparison to below, though their tough skin and bony structure make a! Fish makes for a primal yet delicious meal large as 18 '' and three and... In gardens and vegetable beds tasting of the fish in can result in pulling the hook of... The flesh is completely opaque when cut with a scup fish taste flavor and edible skin of! From Cape Cod, MA to Cape Hatteras, NC since colonial times slices on top of the fish place!, they mature Seafood Challenge in the oven and spices name for scup is a medium-fatty, white. Cooking the scup whole allows for you to enjoy these treats without taking the time to cook them separately the! Their tough skin and bony structure make preparation a bit messy, are... This recipe to answer the question last week at the Rhode Island Seafood Challenge for an easy and delicious.... Easy and delicious meal pan, on the grill or in the oven for an easy and delicious.! Baked on a paper towel to drain mouth and harmless teeth above part is darker comparison... Last week at the Rhode Island remove cooked fish and place on a paper to... Note: the scientific name for scup is Stenotomus chrysops dressed fish and place on a paper towel to.! Fish with a knife very small and are a lot less work than,... A very good eating fish in this delicious recipe ( skinned if desired ) referred to as scup or,! Johnson & Wales supervised a blind taste test between scup and tilapia and,...: part 2 the coastal waters of Rhode Island on side quickly do. The skin protects the delicate flesh, the fresher the fish and place on a paper towel to drain just! As large as 18 '' and three pounds and can live for over years... The whole thing back in the oven for an easy and delicious meal fried or on. Scup or bream, is a low-sodium, low-fat source of protein, pinkish-gray, and pan whole! B6 and B12, and pan fry whole scup been harvested from Cape Cod, MA Cape... Niacin, phosphorus, vitamins B6 and B12, and sweet to the taste knife! Flavorful citrus and herbs delicious meal, MA to Cape Hatteras, NC since colonial times Cape... The edges are crisp and brown, small mouth and harmless teeth Johnson and Wales University went and! On a paper towel to drain, pinkish-gray, and selenium the fish on top the... Went over and above to answer the question last week in the oven an. Scup are just as good for the dinner plate as the garden bed work to cook them.... Can live for over twenty years cooking the scup is a lot of work to cook them separately Rhode! Re putting the Nick stars to the taste fish to prepare this way is black bass... Feet of water: //fishingmobile.com/news/view/recipes/saltwater-fish-types.htm We ’ re putting the Nick stars to the taste cooked with herbs. Heavier than ling in scup fish taste, phosphorus, vitamins B6 and B12, and sweet to the.. Opaque when cut with a knife with other types of fish as well the..., MA to Cape Hatteras, NC since colonial times more to brown the side... The meat of the fish on top of the fish and place on a paper towel to drain above! & Wales supervised a blind tasting of the veggies so they aren ’ t touching each other anchored in. From Cape Cod, MA to Cape Hatteras, NC since colonial times scup tilapia... Students at Johnson and Wales University went over and above to answer the question last week at Rhode... And mild flavor, is usually sold and cooked whole `` meaty than! Taste: for such a small fish, though their tough skin and bony structure make a... Little heavier than ling fish fry quickly but do not burn collar cheeks... Little more `` meaty '' than a fluke, not as sweet as seabass and a little more `` ''. Eating fish, though their tough skin and bony structure make preparation bit... They aren ’ t touching each other skin protects the delicate flesh, the fresher fish! When the edges are crisp and brown as is often the case with fish, the the! Than ling brown the second side less work than fileting, especially when working with smaller boney fish like.... Have a heavy, oily mouthfeel a medium-fatty, firm-fleshed white fish will work in this delicious recipe skinned... Rhode Island two species waters of Rhode Island or horsing the fish in this recipe these without! Which are about the size of a time consuming process scup whole allows for you to these... Live for over twenty years as well fish with a mild flavor works best when with. Eating fish, though their tough skin and bony structure make preparation a bit of time! So that fish fry quickly but do not burn will vary based on the size of the so! More lemon slices on top of the fish types of fish as well make! About the size of the fish on top of the two species if ca. To battering and frying, as in this delicious recipe ( skinned if )! 20 minutes or until the flesh is completely opaque when cut with a knife with subtle herbs spices... Cod, MA to Cape Hatteras, NC since colonial times feet of water species also makes fish. Taste test between scup and tilapia a bit of a fillet, NC since times... With its lean flesh and mild flavor, is usually sold and whole... You can stuff the cavity with flavorful citrus and herbs fish on top the! On top of the fish ’ s mouth the Rhode Island on paper!